Rambler's Top100

Read In Russian

Return home




Russian Air Code




Air Code

Rambler's Top100

Chaos in Sheremetyevo Tender

    Tuesday, November. 18, 2003
    The Moscow Times
    City Hall-connected conglomerate Sistema, a top declared contender for the coveted management contract of Sheremetyevo Airport, was eliminated from the bidding with the announcement of the official tender Monday. The rules of the long-awaited tender, published in Rossiiskaya Gazeta, require bidders to have had assets of at least 60 billion rubles ($2 billion) on Jan. 1, 2003, as assessed by one of the "Big Four" auditing firms.
    In international business parlance, the Big Four designates accounting firms Deloitte & Touche, KPMG, PricewaterhouseCoopers and Ernst & Young.
    The tender, however, leaves out Deloitte, which audits Sistema, and lists Baker McKenzie, a law firm, in its place.
    Deloitte also audits East Line, which manages Domodedovo Airport, and Aeroflot, the heaviest user of Sheremetyevo facilities.
    On Monday most companies involved in the bid had either not heard about the mistake or only read about it in Vedomosti.
    "My first impression is that this is a sorry misunderstanding," said Alexander Dumnov, partner at Deloitte & Touche CIS. "It is so dumb, I don't think anyone could do it intentionally. It goes against both common sense and the principles of competition."
    Dumnov said Deloitte is the leading bookkeeper in the air business, providing 33 percent of all air industry audit services conducted by the Big Four.
    "We still have an open interest in the project, and we are trying to decide our next step now," said Olga Pestereva, head of Sistema's press office.
    Yet the written criteria are definitive and will be enforced, said Alexander Parshukov, a spokesman for the Property Ministry, which drafted the rules. He said the "Big Four" is an off-hand, not a legal, term, and therefore only the companies audited by firms listed in the rules will be considered. He could not say why a law firm was included in the quartet.
    Igor Rotenberg, an official at the Property Ministry and head of the working group on the draft rules, could not be reached for comment Monday. Neither could Yury Isayev, first deputy economic development and trade minister and head of the board of directors of Sheremetyevo.
    "It is unquestionably a mistake, but it only shows that they approached this tender carelessly," said Yelena Sakhnova, transportation analyst at United Financial Group, an investment bank.
    She said other conditions restricting competition for the tender, such as the 60 billion ruble asset minimum, were "not self-evident. It seems like the criteria were picked with Alfa Eco in mind," she said.
    Alfa Eco, a subsidiary of Alfa Group and Sistema's main competitor, is audited by PricewaterhouseCoopers and therefore still eligible to bid.
    Igor Baranovsky, the general director of Alfa Eco Sheremetyevo, a subsidiary of Alfa Eco, said: "This is the first heard I've heard of this. No one has even submitted documents, so no one has been ruled out yet.
    The announcement of the tender is long overdue.
    "It's about time -- with Deloitte or not," said Natasha Zagvozdina, an airlines analyst at Renaissance Capital, referring to the long-delayed appointment of a private manager.
    Sheremetyevo is plagued by poor service, long lines and backed up runways. Airlines have been fleeing for Domodedovo or Vnukovo, two other Moscow airports.
    Aeroflot, which is particularly hamstrung by the overcrowded airport and has invested over $10 million into building a third terminal, is also eager for a solution.
    "Who manages these two terminals is not so important, as long as they are competent people. In the new terminal, however, we would like to play an important and direct role," said Lev Koshlyakov, Aeroflot's deputy general director.
    The so-called Sheremetyevo-3 project has been repeatedly delayed due to disagreements between the airline, Sheremetyevo and the government over equity shares in the company that would build and run the new terminal.
    Contenders have 30 days to submit bids for the tender, Parshukov said.

    Alex Fak
Return to >>Articles ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ----------
Latest headlines
Airbus Signs First Russian Supply Deal
Airbus on Friday awarded Nizhny Novgorod-based Sokol a contract to supply components for its family of passenger jets, the first of several deals that are expected to open the global market to Russia's struggling aerospace industry.

Aviation Industry to Go Private
The government is prepared to take unprecedented steps in turning over the country's aviation industry to private hands, according to a reform concept under discussion by Rosaviakosmos, the Russian Aviation and Space Agency.

Skies to Open for Domestic Airlines
After years of pestering by domestic carriers, the State Civil Aviation Service said Monday that it would finally move to fully liberalize the airline industry by ending its discriminative quota system for domestic passenger flights.

Chaos in Sheremetyevo Tender
City Hall-connected conglomerate Sistema, a top declared contender for the coveted management contract of Sheremetyevo Airport, was eliminated from the bidding with the announcement of the official tender Monday.

Canada Shuts Its Skies to Aeroflot
Canada restricted Aeroflot's access to its airspace on Saturday, forcing Russia's national carrier to reroute all of its flights to and from the U.S. West Coast and cut half of its service to Toronto.

MiG Chief Under Fire, Likely to Be Jettisoned
As the state-owned manufacturer of MiG fighter jets looks set to land its largest-ever defense contract, its director may be heading for the chop.

Eurocopter Eyes Making Choppers in Russia
Eurocopter, the world's leading helicopter company, is in talks with Irkut to assemble its choppers in Russia to tap the country's booming oil and gas services market, a Eurocopter spokesman said Thursday.

Putin Opens an Air Base in Kyrgyzstan
While warplanes looped in the clear skies above, President Vladimir Putin on Thursday opened a Russian military air base and praised the event as a move aimed at strengthening security in the volatile Central Asian region.

The Tu-144: Moscow's Answer to the Concorde
Seated in a conference room at the Tupolev business center, chief designer Alexander Pukhov nodded approvingly as a reporter described her preparations for a first flight on the Concorde and lamented the end of an era of supersonic passenger travel.

A Final Flight of Fancy on Concorde
"Enjoy your ride on the rocket," Captain Adrian Thompson said, welcoming about 100 passengers on board British Airways Flight 001 for New York.

When reprinting, please quote the source and add the link to our website.

Back to top
Copyright © 1997-2005. The AVIA.RU Server is created and maintained by the RusAviaCom Company.
Sponsored by Clintondale Aviation, Inc.